Archive and Search
« It's Sunday! It's Slipknot! It's Sulfur! | Main | Some Rock Gone Wild "Rumors" »

Blame it on the Critics!

I think about the comments on this website and others – and it seems that the majority people are not what I call “cross-over” listeners. That is, listeners tend to really like one genre of music and not much else. Sure, there are exceptions. I listen to quite a bit of different styles of music and I know that’s the case for many of you that read this site. Still, there are people that are “Metal or die!” or even “Opera or nothing.”

Sometimes critics – especially the famous ones that get paid a lot of write for Rolling Stone – help fuel that music divide. Sure, we all have our preferences and favorites, but sometimes I’m even turned off by a band or genre because of what a critic wrote. If a band is immediately compared to another act I despise, that pretty much does it for me. I suppose that’s a shame, really.

I mention all this out of my Eminem posting from a few days back. I wrote that I didn’t like the song (I did, in fact, call it “crap”) but perhaps that was misconstrued. See, I don’t like modern rap – but late 80s and 90s rap is another story. There was a time in which I was a big rap/R&B fan – because about a decade ago, I felt like those sorts of songs didn’t all sound cookie cutter. Today, I have a problem with rap for many reasons, usually because I can’t understand the words and the lyrics are just not smart.

To its credit, Rolling Stone does review a diverse mix of genres – but it’s still usually by acts that are 1) really famous or 2) really hip.

Back in the 80s, Glam was mocked, mocked and mocked some more. I’ve never quite understood that, except that maybe critics couldn’t get past androgyny and staring at men in makeup, shredding a guitar. So while Rolling Stone and their contemporaries back in 1987 were reviewing Motley Crue, they were also praising Bruce Springsteen and U2. Maybe if it wasn’t even intentional, those critics sort of created a rift in the music scene: a “line-in-the-sand” if you will that separated the Glam Metallers from the so-called "smarter" rockers.

Perhaps we should all just be a little more open minded with our music selections?

Reader Comments (6)

ive listened to all types of music, i still do, i just prefer to listen to Rock music, narrow it down more and its mostley Glam.
April 19, 2009 | Unregistered Commenterred6ixx
Great post Allyson!
April 19, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterMichael
Great post. All art is subjective, and it's great that people get so passionate about what they like. For the record, I like Eminem. I've always found his lyrics very clever and in general, he's just fun, and there isn't enough of that any more.
April 19, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterBryon
Perhaps we should all just be a little more open minded with our music selections? Seriously?? I say not only no, but HELL NO! I don't care who reviews what. I don't care what they say in their reviews. I don't care what is famous or hip and least of all I don't care what anyone else thinks about the music I listen to. I am quite capable of thinking for myself. I know what I like and what I don't and I am not going to change that when it comes to anything in life. You should not feel bad for calling Eminem or whoever it was, crap. That is your opinion and you are entitled to it. Now, if I do not give Eminem a chance because you said it was crap then I'm an idiot. A programmed robot waiting on someone to tell me what I like and what I shouldn't. That I am not, nor will ever be. There is a"music divide" because we are all different, thank God. It is ok to listen to various genres of music just as it is ok to be "Metal or Die", Opera or Nothing" if that is what you enjoy. Being yourself is what really matters.
April 19, 2009 | Unregistered Commentertony
i totally agree with tony
April 19, 2009 | Unregistered Commentercrüe düde
So do i with tony, i am after all rock and nothing else
April 21, 2009 | Unregistered CommenterROCKFIGHTER

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.